Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, has fined Meta €805 million — about $887 million — after finding that the Facebook app for Android accessed photos, videos and their metadata on Italian users' phones without specific consent or proper notice.

The decision, first reported in English by Reuters, lands as one of the largest privacy penalties issued in Europe this year, and it arrives at a sensitive moment for platforms whose data practices feed increasingly powerful AI systems. Anyone following the latest AI developments will recognize the pattern: regulators are no longer waiting for data to leak before acting — they are policing how it is collected in the first place.

A Gallery Feature That Read the Whole Phone

At the center of the case is a gallery suggestions feature available since 2023. While users scroll Facebook, the feature offers photos and videos from their phone as ideas for posts.

The Garante found that Facebook requested gallery access with a single permission covering the whole app, following a vague prompt to enable other features. In practice, users could not tell that they were also switching on the gallery suggestions capability — a bundling the regulator treated as consent that was neither free nor informed.

The legal basis matters as much as the finding. Article 122 of Italy's privacy code treats a smartphone as part of a person's private sphere: any access to what the phone holds requires free and informed consent. That rule applies even if no data leaves the phone and no harm is done — access itself is the violation.

Why Italy, Not Ireland

Meta had argued the case belonged with Ireland, where the company's EU base sits and where, under the GDPR's one-stop-shop mechanism, the lead regulator for most cross-border data cases is located.

The Garante disagreed, because it acted under ePrivacy rules, which have no one-stop shop. That distinction gave Italy's watchdog direct jurisdiction, and it is a procedural route other national regulators can copy — a fact likely to worry platforms that have relied on the Irish lead-authority arrangement to slow down enforcement elsewhere in the EU.

20 Million Users and a 0.47% Penalty

The regulator estimated that about 20 million Android users in Italy were affected. In setting the amount, it said it weighed a 2019 decision against Meta and what it described as poor cooperation during the probe. Changes Meta made after the complaint were counted in the company's favour, but the Garante called them late and limited to users who update the app.

The €805 million fine equals roughly 0.47% of Meta's global turnover. It sits close to the €825 million fine a Dutch regulator imposed on Uber, though below the €1.2 billion GDPR penalty Meta received over data transfers.

For scale, the comparison set is striking: this penalty alone is roughly the size of the Dutch Uber fine, and still only a fraction of Meta's own €1.2 billion data-transfer penalty. Whether it changes Meta's behaviour is a different question: a fine equal to 0.47% of turnover is absorbable, and the Garante's own account suggests Meta's earlier fixes came only after the complaint — a dynamic that tends to repeat until enforcement targets product design rather than after-the-fact cleanup.

What Meta Must Do Within 60 Days

The Garante gave Meta 60 days to change how the feature works. The company must ask for separate, specific consent for gallery suggestions, and it must keep the feature off by default — including for users who already granted broad access under the old permission flow.

That remedy is broader than a one-time penalty: it forces a redesign of how the feature obtains permission, and it sets a template other EU regulators could demand for bundled permissions of any kind.

The AI Question the Probe Didn't Answer

Notably, the investigation did not examine whether gallery content was used to train AI systems — something Meta denies. The Garante said it will look separately at a cloud processing feature that Meta launched in 2026, which could bring the analysis closer to how phone content flows into the company's AI infrastructure.

That pending review means the legal exposure is not necessarily settled with this fine. If Italian authorities extend their scrutiny to training and cloud processing, the boundary between a photo-suggestion feature and an AI data pipeline becomes the question — and the €805 million penalty may read, in hindsight, as the opening move.

Meta is also tangling with Italy on a separate front, over a ruling on publisher payments, so its relationship with the country's regulators is unlikely to cool quickly.

For the broader industry, the decision is a reminder that European enforcement is widening its aim: not just at how user data is stored or transferred, but at the moment of collection itself — the tap on 'allow' that everything downstream depends on.

---

Stay Ahead of AI

Get the latest AI news, analysis, and breakthroughs — all in one place.

Read more AI news →