A federal judge in California has refused to throw out a price-fixing lawsuit against Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron, keeping alive claims that the world's three dominant memory makers conspired to constrain the supply of conventional DRAM while steering production toward high-bandwidth memory for AI accelerators. US District Judge Noël Wise of the Northern District of California denied the companies' joint motion to dismiss in full on November 14, finding that the complaint plausibly alleged an agreement in violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Act, according to litigation reporting by LitNews.
The ruling arrives at a fraught moment for anyone who buys memory. Conventional DRAM prices have surged as manufacturers reallocate wafer capacity to HBM, the specialized stacked memory that AI accelerators consume in enormous volumes. For continuing coverage of AI hardware news and the chip industry's AI-driven transformation, AI Buzz Wire tracks the supply decisions behind the price tags.
The Allegations at the Heart of the Case
The proposed class action was filed on June 25, 2026 by 17 consumers and small businesses from five states. It targets conventional DRAM — the standardized memory chips built to industry specifications for computers, phones and servers — rather than the exotic HBM stacks that sit beside AI GPUs.
According to the complaint, the three defendants controlled more than 91 percent of global DRAM revenue as of the third quarter of 2025. The document alleges they began cutting conventional DRAM production in late 2022 and, starting in 2023, shifted capacity to HBM, a product the complaint notes requires roughly three to four times the silicon wafer area per gigabyte compared with conventional DDR5 DRAM.
The pricing consequences alleged are stark. By the third quarter of 2025, conventional DRAM prices had risen 171.8 percent in a single year, and 697 percent over 18 months, according to the complaint. Yet, it alleges, "not one of the three Defendants expanded or announced plans to meaningfully expand commodity DRAM production capacity."
Why the Court Said This Is Not 'DRAM II'
The defendants argued the suit was a rerun of DRAM II, the Ninth Circuit's 2022 decision affirming dismissal of an earlier conspiracy case against the same three companies over a 2016–2018 supply restriction. "The Court finds that it is not," Judge Wise wrote.
Because the plaintiffs lack direct evidence of an agreement, the case turned on so-called plus factors — facts that make collusion more plausible than ordinary parallel conduct. Judge Wise found the complaint packed with them: long-term contracts locking in HBM supply, reported refusals by Samsung and SK Hynix to sign long-term agreements with major conventional DRAM customers, and Micron's December 3, 2025 announcement that it would close Crucial, its 30-year-old consumer brand.
Those moves, the judge wrote, are "difficult if not impossible to unwind," and combined with fab construction delays and the refusal to expand despite record prices, are "the sort that at the pleading stage, it appears no reasonable firm would make without a prior agreement." She cited the Ninth Circuit's 1990 Petroleum Products precedent, which observed that changes in production capacity are not readily reversible.
Timing helped the plaintiffs too. SK Hynix and Micron announced supply cuts three weeks apart in late 2022, and Samsung's roughly four-and-a-half-month lag, until April 7, 2023, was "not such an unreasonably long delay that it defeats an allegation of parallel conduct," the judge wrote. The complaint also cites the companies' prior cartel history and near-identical customer vetting practices as plus factors.
The court was selective, however. It gave no weight to three of the plaintiffs' arguments: investor statements about "supply discipline," which resembled language DRAM II had already held insufficient; executive meetings at industry conferences, absent specifics about what was exchanged; and the three-company market structure itself, which the judge called neutral.
What Happens Next
The defendants must answer the complaint by December 7, 2026, and the initial case management conference is set for January 12, 2027. Nothing has been proven. The allegations are accepted as true only at the pleading stage, and the companies will now fight the case on the merits — where the standard of proof is far higher.
Still, surviving a motion to dismiss is the critical hurdle in private antitrust litigation, because it unlocks discovery: internal emails, capacity plans and pricing documents that the plaintiffs' allegations could never reach on their own. Given how central HBM allocation has become to each company's AI strategy, those files could prove uncomfortable.
For consumers and businesses, the case reframes the memory crunch not as an unavoidable side effect of the AI boom, but as a possibly coordinated choice — one a federal judge now finds plausible enough to litigate. Whether the evidence sustains that theory is a question for the next two years. The plaintiffs' lawyers, the defendants and the court all agree on one thing: the answer will not come quickly.
Stay Ahead of AI
From memory markets to model launches, the AI story moves fast. Stay ahead of AI with AI Buzz Wire's coverage of the developments that matter.
Read more AI news →